Lost in Translation
Modernist landscapes of the 1960s and '70s reflect the idealism of the times. Now they're being replaced with designs for a less hopeful age.
BY PAUL BENNETT
Every year, in cities
and suburbs across America, significant works of modernist
landscape architecture succumb to the bulldozer. In
recent years, major landscapes by Lawrence Halprin,
M. Paul Friedberg, Dan Kiley, Hideo Sasaki, and others
have been demolished or are in the process of demolition
or teetering on the edge. Although architects have
done a good job educating the public about the importance
of modernist buildings, most of us could walk past
a Kiley, or Halprin, or Friedberg landscape in New
York, Minneapolis, or San Francisco and never know
the difference. But their loss, some say, is just
as grave as the loss of a Frank Lloyd Wright or Richard
Neutra houseor perhaps more so. It can be argued
that, in the context of city life, landscapes are
more important than architecture, that they embody
civic values, and that as they disappear, so does
our understanding of place.
In Denver, one such modernist landscape
was razed last summer. Halprin designed Skyline Park
in 1973 as part of a downtown urban renewal scheme.
The park, though not regarded as one of his most important
works, nonetheless contained many of his hallmarks.
A berm raised along the edge of the space created
a sense of separation from the city street, and three
signature fountains punctuated the line of the park,
animating the space with a play of water. (Halprin,
who designed the FDR Memorial in Washington, D.C.,
is perhaps most famous for these open-plan fountains
in San Francisco, Fort Worth, Tex., and Portland,
Ore.) Planters, seating, paving material, and grade
changes were conceived as parts of a geometric whole.
Although abstract, the jagged forms, paved canyons,
and pinkish-hued cement made allusions to Rocky Mountain
landscapes.
For more of this story,
subscribe
to the magazine, look for the May/June
2004 issue on newsstands, or e-mail
us to purchase a copy.
Read more excerpts from our current
issue.
|